Meet the scientist moms fighting climate change for their children
| Tucson, Ariz.
Joellen Russell likes a big class. The bigger the better, actually, with online sections and huge auditoriums and students swarming her after a lecture 鈥� the way they did one Thursday morning this fall after her Intro to Oceanography course at the University of Arizona.
鈥淲ait, Dr. Russell, I鈥檓 not sure about the homework.鈥澛�
鈥淲hat about the jet stream?鈥�
Why We Wrote This
A group of female scientists is trying to overcome climate 鈥渄oomerism鈥� 鈥� the idea that nothing can be done to stop global warming. For them, it鈥檚 not just about the science but about values: how the issue affects families.
鈥淒r. Russell! I saw your sweet family at CVS!鈥�
The distinguished professor stays onstage, laughing, joking, answering question after question, until finally she suggests that anyone else who wants to talk should visit her during office hours, which she holds at a picnic table outside.聽
鈥淚t鈥檚 a bit of a circus,鈥� she says as she walks out of the voluminous lecture hall. 鈥淏ut, I like it when it鈥檚 noisy. I like it when they want to talk and they want to tell you things and they want to ask things.鈥� She grins, as if getting away with something. 鈥淚t鈥檚 fun.鈥� 聽
The university鈥檚 administrators have suggested that perhaps Dr. Russell might want to teach smaller, more exclusive seminars. That, after all, is what鈥檚 typical for tenured professors with named chairs and multimillion-dollar grants and international partnerships on the cutting edge of scientific research. But Dr. Russell knows that students who take her introductory class are more likely than other undergraduates to enroll in another science course. They are also more likely to graduate. And that, she believes, means they are more likely to join her in what she sees as the biggest, most important fight for humankind today 鈥� a battle not only against climate change, but also against those who say there鈥檚 nothing anyone can do about it. 聽
And she wants to grow an army of resilience.聽
鈥淢y job is not to just advance the science,鈥� she says. 鈥淚t鈥檚 to build the next front lines. I launch as many as I can.鈥澛�
Dr. Russell is not alone in this mobilization. Across the scientific world, there is a growing movement not only to show the way climate systems are changing, but also to fight what has become known as climate 鈥渄oomerism,鈥� the idea that there鈥檚 simply nothing we can do about global warming, whether because of China鈥檚 coal plants or domestic ignorance or just that we鈥檝e run out of time. This effort is founded on resilience 鈥� both collective and personal. Many of the key players in this rejection of despair are women. Many are mothers. And many are taking aim at long-held norms and assumptions of the higher education establishment, whether it鈥檚 what type of classes to teach, how research is shared 鈥� or, most recently, how scientists incorporate their families into their work. One new group, called Science Moms, is working to take this movement public, connecting female climate scientists who have children to other mothers in an effort to spread information about climate change. 聽
鈥淲omen are creating space for different kinds of reactions to the climate crisis and opening up that conversation,鈥� says Jacquelyn Gill, a climate scientist and paleoecologist at the University of Maine in Orono. 鈥淭he discourse itself has changed.鈥�
Dr. Russell鈥檚 journey is an example of this. Over her career, she has expanded her understanding of resilience from something personal to a collective force, from scientific achievement to a broader embrace of humanity. Her story is a mirror, in many ways, of the approach to global warming writ large: how people, groups, and societies around the world are beginning to integrate climate into the way they think, live, and act.聽
鈥淚 finally found my united voice,鈥� Dr. Russell says. 鈥淚t turns out that my students and my community members and my kids鈥� classroom teachers and all the rest of them were waiting for me to shake off the shackles of 鈥榡ust the science鈥� and talk to them about the values part. And I am thrilled.鈥澛�
For her, this new kind of resilience starts with Joseph and Maeve. Joseph is 14 years old now; Maeve is 11. And not all that long ago, Dr. Russell says, she would have been uncomfortable talking about her children at work. Not because she didn鈥檛 adore them. To the contrary, she has been enthralled with these 鈥渟moochie babies鈥� since before their births. She snuggles with them on the couch, reads 鈥淗arry Potter鈥� to them at night, and splashes with them in the pool. But she learned early that in the geophysical sciences 鈥� a field in which only 27% of U.S. faculty members are women, according to one recent study 鈥� motherhood was suspect. 聽
That lesson seemed to come from everywhere. As a graduate student making her first expedition to the Southern Ocean, Dr. Russell had to take a pregnancy test before being allowed on the research ship. That鈥檚 still standard practice, she says. 鈥淣o man knows how that feels,鈥� she says.聽
She had colleagues who called women with children 鈥渂reeders鈥�; she knew the stories of friends denied positions because supervisors suspected they would 鈥渏ust get pregnant and leave.鈥� And while there were a growing number of women joining the scientific ranks, very few had families.聽
鈥淚t was just normal to not have kids if you wanted to be a scientist, at least in the fieldwork-type sciences,鈥� she says. 聽
So when, by surprise, she became pregnant soon after she got to the University of Arizona, Dr. Russell panicked. There were no other mothers on the tenure track in her department. Her husband, Paul Goodman, was also an academic but had left his prior position so she could take the job in Tucson. Hers was their primary salary. When she Googled 鈥渕aternity policy鈥� for the university, she discovered that there was no paid leave.聽
For 4 1/2 months, she tried to hide her pregnancy. She kept thinking about an experience she had as an undergraduate at Harvard University in the early 1990s,聽when she had joined a research team in Hawaii, trudging through mud in the Alakai Swamp, collecting soil samples with two male professors and a female postdoctoral student. Dr. Russell recalls the postdoc pulled her aside at one point, frantic. The young woman was pregnant but had been trying to hide it because she thought it would threaten her position, which was up for review.
鈥淪o we sneaked all of her gear into my backpack so that she wouldn鈥檛 have to carry anything,鈥� Dr. Russell says. 鈥淚t was over 125 pounds; I weighed 130. And I lifted that freaking pack and I carried it out because ... the idea that they would find out, or that she would lose the kid ...鈥� she trails off.
The men never knew what was going on. The postdoc eventually had a healthy baby and kept her job. But the lesson for 20-year-old Ms. Russell was clear: The way to survive motherhood in the sciences was to pretend your babies did not exist.聽
Dr. Russell eventually worked up the courage to tell her department chair at the University of Arizona that she was pregnant. But even after the big hug she got in response; even after her male colleagues wandered down the hall to ask whether, just this semester, she might let them teach one of her courses because, well, they鈥檇 never taught oceanography before and it might be interesting; even though she recognized that they were trying to lighten her load to make up for the university鈥檚 lack of maternity leave 鈥� she still was scared, still determined to show that motherhood would not change her work.聽
That, she thought, was resilience. After all, this sort of determination had always worked for her. 聽
As a child growing up north of the Arctic Circle by the Chukchi Sea, in a Native fishing village where her father worked for the U.S. government鈥檚 Indian Health Service, she dreamed of one day following the sea ice, to understand what happened after it broke up and floated away. A relative told her that the best place to learn about that would be the Scripps Institution of Oceanography at the University of California, San Diego. The young Joellen scrawled 鈥淪cripps or bust鈥� on her Converse sneakers.
When the family moved to rural Montana for her father鈥檚 next posting, the local school system did not offer calculus or geometry 鈥� skills Joellen knew she would need if she wanted to go to Scripps. She convinced her parents to let her apply to boarding school and was accepted on financial aid to the prestigious St. Paul鈥檚 School in New Hampshire. 鈥淚 wanted to learn. I was so desperate,鈥� says Dr. Russell. 鈥淎nd so I studied and I studied and I studied and I hustled and I hustled.鈥� 聽
When she discovered, to her heartbreak, that Scripps was a graduate program only, and that she would need to go to college first, she applied for financial aid at all the schools her advisers recommended. Harvard gave her the most monetary support, so she went there, waking up each night to the traffic and sirens on Massachusetts Avenue.
From there she did go to Scripps. She also voyaged to the Southern Ocean, where albatross circled the massive waves like fighter jets. She took positions at the University of Washington, and then Princeton, and eventually came to Arizona, where she began building a supercomputer system that would help untangle one of the big puzzles of modern climate science: how the oceans both slow and accelerate聽atmospheric warming. She was figuring out what happened to the sea ice.
So when she became pregnant, Dr. Russell was determined to continue that work.聽
When Maeve came, three years later, in 2010, there was still no paid maternity leave. So Dr. Russell put on compression stockings and boarded planes so she could network with colleagues on both coasts to put together a multimillion-dollar interdisciplinary grant application. They wanted to build and deploy hundreds of robot floats with sensors to record temperature, oxygen, and other chemistry at various depths in the Southern Ocean. She lugged a giant, plug-in breast pump to conferences and through airports, sitting with it on the dirty floor of Los Angeles International Airport 鈥� the only place near an outlet back then 鈥� and hoping none of her colleagues walked by.聽
Her father flew in from Montana to help her husband when she had work trips. She started investigating how to use artificial intelligence and advanced technology in climate modeling, and continued building out the National Science Foundation-funded SOCCOM, or Southern Ocean Carbon and Climate Observation and Modeling, project.聽 聽
At the same time, the climate crisis was accelerating. The 2010s was the warmest decade in recorded history, kicked off by heat waves and wildfires in Russia. Soon there would be floods in Pakistan and Bangladesh, and droughts in East Africa. 聽
Although most nations had agreed to emissions-limiting goals set forth in the 2015 Paris Agreement, in 2019 carbon dioxide levels in the atmosphere passed a measurement of 410 parts per million 鈥� the highest concentration of the greenhouse gas in 3 million years. That鈥檚 the year Dr. Russell became a full professor. More heat waves swept across both the Arctic and Europe. In Tucson, the summers became oppressive. She understood, as thoroughly and intimately as anyone, the mechanisms of what was happening with the climate, and how these extreme weather events were connected to the geochemical data sets she analyzed at work. She was also a parent, distraught when Maeve got heatstroke trying to ride her bike. She woke up earlier and earlier to walk the family dogs so they wouldn鈥檛 burn their paws on the pavement.
But that personal world, and any emotions about what was happening to her children鈥檚 futures, was something separate from her work. Then, Dr. Russell got an email.聽
Katharine Hayhoe is a well-known atmospheric scientist who is a distinguished professor at Texas Tech University in Lubbock and chief scientist for The Nature Conservancy.聽She is also an evangelical 海角大神, and her work communicating about climate change across political demographics has gained her a sort of celebrity status in the scientific and climate advocacy worlds. 聽
Dr. Hayhoe was reaching out to a group of female climate scientists who were also mothers, she explained, with the goal of building an outreach and awareness campaign. She wanted Dr. Russell to be one of the founding members of the group, which would be called Science Moms.
Dr. Russell remembers hesitating.
By that point she had already been trying, in her own small way, to change the professional norms around parents. She regularly told the younger women in her department 鈥� and the younger men, for that matter 鈥� that they should have their own lives; that they should have families and babies, if that鈥檚 what they wanted; that they should make time for pets and parents. She urged them to take advantage of the university鈥檚 paid parental leave program, which the school started offering in 2014.
Dr. Russell believed in sharing research as well, embracing open-source data and encouraging her graduate students to take lead authorship on journal articles. She wanted to avoid the traditional practice of hoarding research for individual glory and instead create a model that was broader and more inclusive.聽
But to face the world and identify as a mother 鈥� that was different. That would require a different type of resilience.
The idea for Science Moms grew out of a collaboration between Dr. Hayhoe and John Marshall, the former chief strategy officer at Lippincott, a marketing consulting firm, as well as Dan Schrag, director of Harvard鈥檚 Center for the Environment. Mr. Marshall and Dr. Schrag had formed a nonpartisan nonprofit called the Potential Energy Coalition to, as they put it, 鈥渃hange the narrative鈥� on climate change.
Mr. Marshall had spent years as a successful executive in the advertising and marketing industry when his 17-year-old son suggested, somewhat bluntly, that perhaps he should stop using his skills to get people to spend money and instead make the world a better place. It was a thought-shifting moment, Mr. Marshall remembers.
Soon, he and Dr. Schrag were talking about climate change 鈥� a problem that impacted every human on Earth, but one that had become unnecessarily political. They wanted to get more people to both care about climate change and demand action to address it 鈥� but without taking a particular partisan or policy stance. After running analytics, Mr. Marshall determined that among all U.S. demographics, mothers age 40-55 were the most likely to be moved on the issue. They were worried about their children鈥檚 futures but felt uneducated about climate science and didn鈥檛 know what to do about global warming.聽
Mr. Marshall realized he needed the right messenger to reach this group. He wanted someone who would be trustworthy and relatable, but also knowledgeable. And he knew from his for-profit work that the more authentic the storyteller, the better.聽
鈥淥ur work has focused on elevating new spokespeople, spokespeople that everyday Americans can relate to,鈥� Mr. Marshall says.聽
At the same time, Dr. Hayhoe had been working on her own efforts to increase the conversation about climate change. In a TED Talk viewed almost 4 million times, she argued that the most important thing people could do to fight climate change was to talk about it 鈥� something she and others believed wasn鈥檛 happening enough around American dinner tables. She has also written a book, "Saving Us," about聽what individuals can do to make a difference on the issue.
Mr. Marshall and Dr. Schrag reached out to Dr. Hayhoe to share their marketing research and get advice. Soon, the three coalesced around the idea for Science Moms 鈥� a way to bring together a group of climate scientists who were mothers to connect with other mothers in their communities.聽
The team, led by Dr. Hayhoe, reached out to Emily Fischer and Melissa Burt at Colorado State University in Fort Collins, and Tracey Holloway, a professor at the University of Wisconsin-Madison who founded the Earth Science Women鈥檚 Network. And they reached out to Dr. Russell.
For Dr. Russell, Dr. Hayhoe was the right person to pitch the idea of Science Moms. She was another scientist from a red state who was decidedly, publicly, nonpartisan. But Dr. Russell was still nervous, wondering whether her male colleagues would think she was 鈥減laying鈥� on her motherhood, or whether she would be seen as 鈥渓ess serious鈥� by talking about being a mom. 聽
She wasn鈥檛 the only scientist who worried about this. 鈥淚 mean, that鈥檚 always an issue, right?鈥� says Dr. Fischer, one of the group鈥檚 co-founders.
But as Dr. Fischer says, everyone in that group also knew, intimately, the importance of taking a stand. 鈥淚 lead a very large mentoring program for women,鈥� she says. 鈥淪o I understand very well the research on role modeling for women. And so, when I feel this question, this 鈥榟ow is this going to be perceived by my colleagues that don鈥檛 have children,鈥� I know I have a larger purpose.鈥�
To Dr. Russell, it was one of the first times she felt she could integrate, rather than separate, these different parts of her identity 鈥� the scientist and the mother. And looking at the Zoom screen filled with colleagues in the same situation, she felt a new type of strength. A new resilience. They were like a group of penguins, she says, encouraging each other, nudging each other to the cliff, diving off en masse and hoping they wouldn鈥檛 get eaten by the seals.
Since the group started, the scientists have recorded videos about both climate science and their children, which together have been viewed more than 440 million times. They have participated in livestreamed town hall conversations and gone on television to talk about climate change from a parenting perspective. They have brainstormed new ways of breaking down complex climate data to a lay audience, met with groups of nonscientist mothers, and helped with social media and advertising campaigns.聽
鈥淚t鈥檚 a testament to the human spirit that the people who know the whole story, how serious it is, they鈥檙e the ones who work the hardest,鈥� says Mr. Marshall. 鈥淵es, it鈥檚 resilience. But the why behind the whole thing is love.鈥�
And it鈥檚 that same love, Dr. Russell says, that she can bring to the university lecture hall, or to the office hours with the line of students wanting to share their dreams, or when sitting down at dinner next to her children eating Paul鈥檚 famous vegetable lasagna.聽
It鈥檚 the same love, the same person, the same resilience. And it can change the world, she believes. So yes, she wants big classes, big tents, big movements.
Over the past weeks, the Science Moms founders have written letters to their children, which many have shared publicly. 聽
鈥淭o my smoochie babies,鈥� Dr. Russell wrote. 鈥淚 chose this life to help build a better world for you.聽
鈥淚 hope that when you鈥檙e grown, you鈥檒l forgive me for being the 鈥榯ired鈥� mama. The 鈥榞one to the field鈥� mama. The 鈥榦bsessed with the new data鈥� mama. Because the climate is changing so fast, and will affect your world so much, I鈥檝e had to become your 鈥榞ladiator science鈥� mama so I can fight every day 鈥� for you.鈥�
