Historically, the Fourth of July has been as much about toppling statues as about grilling hot dogs, as presidents and various groups have used the holiday to advance different views of American citizenship.
Some metaphors, Walter Robinson told me, write themselves.
At Philadelphia鈥檚 National Constitution Center, the historic homesite of James Dexter, a former enslaved person who co-founded the Free African Society in 1787, was nearly paved over to be a bus drop-off. It was saved by African American activists.
鈥淲hat could be a more amazing metaphor than to cover over something so聽key to Black self-determination?鈥 asks the Black composer, writer, and activist.
His article 鈥The other side of liberty鈥 ran in the Monitor on July 3, 2003. Its examination of how freedom and slavery have been interlinked since the country鈥檚 founding 鈥 and the need for Americans to fully understand their history 鈥 echoes now. To Mr. Robinson, 鈥渢he entire Atlantic Basin could be yellow taped as a 360-year crime scene.鈥
Yet he is an optimist, citing progress including the creation of the National Museum of African American History and Culture in Washington and the National Memorial for Peace and Justice聽in Montgomery, Alabama.
As the article notes, at the same moment they declared that all men were created equal, many of America鈥檚 Founding Fathers enslaved others.
鈥淐an we accept our venerated Founding Fathers like George Washington as complex people who owned slaves and extended the length of the Atlantic Slave Trade in our Constitution?鈥澛燤r. Robinson asks. America acknowledges Washington as a freedom fighter. 鈥淐an we accept and lift up Black freedom fighters who broke the existing laws, like Harriet Tubman or Denmark Vesey, as patriots and true defenders of the precious ideals of our democracy? These are challenges to be overcome and resolved.鈥
Mr. Robinson, who composed a musical about Vesey and the Charleston Slave Conspiracy of 1822, quotes the words of a co-conspirator sentenced to hang in a trial closed to the public. A white minister urged him to repent. 鈥淪in? What sin? 鈥 Washington was a white man and you idolized him; but I, alas, am a black man, and you hang me for the very act you applauded in him.鈥澛犅
If you listen to today鈥檚 audio edition, you can hear an excerpt from 鈥淧reamble,鈥 from Mr. Robinson鈥檚 musical, 鈥淟ook What a Wonder.鈥