海角大神

Did General Motors prompt Michigan's 'anti-Tesla' law?

Michigan Governor Rick Snyder signed a bill into law yesterday effectively banning Tesla from setting up shop in the Wolverine state. He did so after General Motors, a major  Michigan employer, issued a statement supporting the so-called 'anti-Tesla' bill. 

|
Carlos Osorio/AP/File
Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder speaks during a Republican rally in Troy, Mich. Snyder signed a bill into law this week preventing Tesla from doing business in the state, immediately after General Motors issued a statement in support of the bill.

Last week, we told you about聽聽that would聽聽Tesla from setting up shop in the Wolverine State. It had passed both houses of the legislature and was headed to Governor Rick Snyder's desk. The only question remaining was: would Snyder sign it?

Then yesterday, according to聽, General Motors officially voiced support for the bill. Shortly thereafter,聽.听

The latter isn't surprising. Even though Snyder is a Republican, and even though Republicans have often agreed -- in principle -- with allowing Tesla to sell directly to consumers and let the marketplace determine its success or failure, he is the governor of Michigan, homebase for America's Big Three automakers. It seems logical that he'd try to protect those聽, which employ huge numbers of Michiganders.*

奥丑补迟听is聽surprising, though, is that GM would announce support for the bill. Sure, it makes sense for GM to approve of it, but why issue a statement in support? No other automaker went that far.听

There are a range of possibilities, but two seem likelier than most.听

It's entirely possible that dealers encouraged GM to make a public show of support. Snyder's reluctance to state whether he would sign or veto the measure clearly indicated some ambivalence on his part, so it makes perfect sense that members of the聽Michigan Automobile Dealers Association, which lobbied hard for the bill, would encourage GM to weigh in. To hear an opinion from such a huge corporation could've been a determining factor in Synder's decision.

It's also possible that GM sees Tesla as a threat. At this point, it's not a significant threat to GM's bottom line. However, Tesla's new business model -- web-centric, commission-free, haggle-free -- could encourage dealers and consumers to demand changes in the status quo. Those changes could affect what consumers are willing to pay for聽, the ebb and flow of money between dealerships and GM, or any number of things that GM (and its shareholders) would dislike.听

It appears that Tesla has no recourse in Michigan: the bill is now law. However, if significant numbers of consumers begin crossing state lines to purchase Tesla vehicles -- or if the blowback against GM and dealers becomes too severe -- maybe that will change.

* For what it's worth, Snyder says that the new law doesn't affect Tesla because car companies were already prohibited from selling directly to consumers under state law.听, however, Tesla notes that the law imposes a range of new restrictions: "聽It also seeks to prevent Tesla from operating a gallery in Michigan that simply provides information without conducting sales. We could even be barred from telling people about our car."

You've read  of  free articles. Subscribe to continue.
Real news can be honest, hopeful, credible, constructive.
海角大神 was founded in 1908 to lift the standard of journalism and uplift humanity. We aim to 鈥渟peak the truth in love.鈥 Our goal is not to tell you what to think, but to give you the essential knowledge and understanding to come to your own intelligent conclusions. Join us in this mission by subscribing.
QR Code to Did General Motors prompt Michigan's 'anti-Tesla' law?
Read this article in
/Business/In-Gear/2014/1023/Did-General-Motors-prompt-Michigan-s-anti-Tesla-law
QR Code to Subscription page
Start your subscription today
/subscribe